05 May 2009

Analysis: EU promotes success of convoys

The European Union says its registration and convoy system has succeeded in protecting all but one ship from pirate attacks off Somalia in an article published today by Lloyds List.
“Since 12 December 2008, 41 attacks have been
confirmed in the area of operations, resulting in seven actual hijackings. Only one of the seven hijacked vessels was following EU Navfor recommendations,” said the EU Council of Ministers, referring to the period to March 1.
The piece continues,
Rather than being escorted, commercial vessels are organized into convoys which are then watched over by EU navy vessels stationed at strategic points. Ship operators register vessels over a website and are given convoy start times and locations. “The EU mission is not alone in the region,” the Council of Ministers pointed out. “Efficient coordination both with the shipping industry and with other naval units deployed by maritime powers (Russia, China and India) or groups (US-led coalition TF 151 + NATO) is therefore essential. “The Maritime Security Centre (Horn of Africa) website, developed by Operational Headquarters in conjunction with the shipping industry, and voluntary exchange of information and best practices are the means through which efficient coordination is being achieved.”
(ONI Worldwide Threat to Shipping, 5/13/09)

Incident: Victoria taken

The German owned cargo ship Victoria is taken in the Gulf of Aden while travelling in military convoy. The pirates attacked the Antigua and Barbuda flagged vessel while it was being escorted with a cargo of rice for Jeddah. It was taken to Bossaso with its crew of 11. (Bloomberg, 05/06/09)

Lloyd's says the ship was not in convoy: "the ship had registered its presence with the European Union’s anti-piracy naval mission Atalanta and had been sailing inside the transit corridor monitored by naval forces." (Lloyd's List, 05/06/09)

03 May 2009

Incident: Seychelles re-arrest three pirates

Three pirates released by the French warship Nivose have been re-arrested by the Seychelles coast guard. No details. (AP, 05/03/09)

Incident:France captures 11 pirates

Two Somali fast craft bearing armed men closed with the French warship 600 miles off the coast of Africa in the Indian Ocean. Eleven armed pirates were arrested after they realized their mistake. (Reuters, 05/03/09)

The ship in question was the French frigate Nivôse.
...mistaken for a merchant ship, Nivôse sailed into the sun to avoid being identified; as the pirates closed in, she turned about, launching her on-boarded helicopter and fast outboard vessels.
(Wikipedia, "List of ships attacked by Somali pirates," 12/31/09)

02 May 2009

Incident: Tanker attacked

A tanker, not otherwise identified, is fired upon in the Indian Ocean some 320NM southwest of Port Victoria, Seychelles.
A mother ship and two speed boats were observed at a distance of 6NM from the vessel. The captain altered course and the boats started chasing the vessel. The captain raised the alarm, sent
out a distress message, increased speed, and took evasive maneuvers.
The attackers desisted once their distance from the mothership reached 20 km. (ONI Worldwide Threat to Shipping, 5/27/09)

Incident: General cargo ship taken

A general cargo ship, not otherwise identified, is hijacked off Mogadishu. No details. (ICC/IMB Website)

Incident: Product tanker fired upon

A product tanker, not otherwise identified, is fired upon in the Indian Ocean by men in two speedboats.
A pirate mother vessel and two high speedboats were observed at a distance of six nm from a tanker underway. Master altered course and the boats started chasing the tanker. Master raised alarm, sent distress message, increased speed and took evasive manoeuvres. The boats came very close to the tanker and suddenly the 2nd boat stopped chasing the tanker, probably engine problem. The 1st boat fired upon the tanker with RPG and aborted the attack as the distance from the mother vessel increased to 20 nm. No damages and injuries to crew.
The attack occurred 560 NM southeast of Mogadishu. (ICC/IMB Website)

01 May 2009

Incident: Bulk carrier escapes boarding try

A bulk carrier operating in the Indian Ocean, not otherwise identified, escaped a boarding attempt 270NM east of Port Victoria, Seychelles, after 40 minutes of evasive maneuvering. Two speed boats pursued their target, firing small arms and rocket propelled grenades and inflicting minor damage on the ship. The pirates made a total of five failed boarding attempts using a small ladder to try to scale the high freeboard. (ONI Worldwide Threat to Shipping, 5/27/09)

Incident: Almezaan taken

The ship Almezaan is captured by pirates 100 NM off Somalia in the Indian Ocean. No details. (ONI Worldwide Threat to Shipping, 5/27/09)

Incident: Vessel chased

A vessel, not otherwise identified, was chased 220NM southeast of Port Victoria,
Seychelles, in the Indian Ocean by a suspicious craft. The chase lasted 20 minutes, ending thanks to evasive action by the captain of the pursued ship. (ONI Worldwide Threat to Shipping, 5/27/09)

Incident: Al Misan taken

A Pakistani-owned ship, the Al Misan, is taken 60 miles off Mogadishu while carrying vehicles, sugar, and cooking oils from the UAE. A Somali trader with a stake in the ship or cargo said negotiations to free the vessel are underway. (AFP, 05/03/09)

Incident: Kition attacked

The Norwegian oil tanker Kition is attacked 161 km off the Somali coast but rescued by the Portuguese warship Corte Real. A Portuguese helicopter followed the attackers back to their mothership, arrested 19 men, then released them. (Xinhua, 05/02/09) "... the Portuguese found four sticks of P4A explosives on the vessel." (VOA, 05/02/09)

Incident: Ariana seized

A Malta-flagged Greek tanker, the Ariana, is taken in the Indian Ocean between the Seychelles and Madagascar while carrying soy from Brazil to Iran. Its crew of 24 Ukrainians was made hostage with the ship. No details (Xinhua, 5/2/09)

The attack occurred late Friday. (Xinhua, 5/2/09)

There is a British national among the crew in a managerial role. (VOA, 05/02/09)

CNN calls Ariana British-owned. (CNN, 05/02/09)

The ship is Greek-owned and registered in Malta. (Wikipedia, "List of ships attacked by Somali pirates," 12/31/09)

Analysis: Tangled military commands

One of the clear threads we described in the 2008 Yearbook was the devolution of military control throughout the year. The year began with a near unitary command situation: US Admiral Bill Gortney's US Navy forces dominated the region.

With the dramatic increase in piracy after commercial ships were herded into a patrol zone where no navy patrolled and after listening to various sociology and philosophy lessons given merchant seafarers by Admiral Gortney, the international community rose to the military challenge and sent navies to the region, taking care to keep those navies out of the hands of Gortney. Gortney's new CTF 151, a dedicated anti-piracy force intended to absorb various international contingents, attracted only the odd ship from America's closest allies. (Its website portrays an idle, self-absorbed command casting a lazy eye on news headlines from the region.)

In 2008, we watched independent Indian, Chinese, Russian, French and other flotillas rescue attacked ships, escort flagged vessels of their own nationality, and (too often) arrive late at the scene of a crime. Most curiously we saw the dispatch of allied fleets (from NATO and the EU) arrive to perform missions outside of any unifying leadership, U.S. or otherwise.

World Politics Review now suggests that the EU and NATO are "interblocking" in their bilateral dealings:
NATO and the EU now coexist with a confusing and ambiguous set of overlapping tasks, with no clear functional or geographical division of labor in the cards anytime soon. Nor have they signed any formal agreements regarding information sharing, security guarantees and a code of conduct, despite having troops [sailors], often from the same country, serving side by side in harm's way. Playing it by ear is the order of the day. Instead of interlocking, the two institutions have become interblocking.
Note that "NATO" refers to a separate command in the region, not to allied forces working under CTF 150 or CTF 151. Each of these CTFs has a different purpose as does the U.S. Fifth Fleet in the region.

Amidst this chaos - and we have not even considered independent forces here - we learn that NATO wants to revise its anti-piracy mission:
...the alliance has asked its military planners to come up with a stronger mandate and new rules of engagement for the mission ... a key issue is determining how to deal with captured pirates. NATO ships in recent weeks have captured several boatloads of suspected pirates but had to release them because of legal concerns.
None of this seems destined to influence command and control and the need for effective cooperation.

Incident: France releases pirate suspects

Three men captured on what appeared to be a mothership are released by "the captain of the French frigate Nivose." Nivose, on duty with an EU squadron, found gear on the captured vessel from the hijacked Bow Asir but no weapons. The suspected mothership, raided yesterday, was found "420 nautical miles east of the Somali coast in the Seychelles Exclusive Economic Zone." (AFP, 05/01/09)